T. Kavanagh et al., QUALITY-OF-LIFE AND CARDIORESPIRATORY FUNCTION IN CHRONIC HEART-FAILURE - EFFECTS OF 12 MONTHS AEROBIC TRAINING, HEART, 76(1), 1996, pp. 42-49
Objective-To examine the long-term benefits and safety of aerobic trai
ning in patients with chronic heart failure. Design-Non-randomised con
trol trial with 52 weeks follow up. Setting-Outpatient cardiac rehabil
itation referral centre. Patients-Patients with compensated chronic he
art failure (mean (SD) age 62 (6) years, New York Heart Association st
age III, initial resting ejection fraction 22 (7)%). Experimental grou
p of 17 men, 4 women; control group 8 men, 1 woman. Interventions-Expe
rimental group: progressive, supervised aerobic walking programme for
52 weeks. Control group: standard medical treatment. Main outcome meas
ures-Six-minute walk distance, progressive cycle ergometer test to sub
jective exhaustion, disease-specific quality of life questionnaire, an
d standard gamble test, all measured at entry, 4, 8, 12, 16, 26, and 5
2 weeks. Results-Control data showed no changes except a small trend t
o improved emotional function (P = 0.02 at 12 weeks only). Fifteen of
the 21 patients completed all 52 weeks of aerobic training; two withdr
ew for non-cardiac reasons (16, 52 weeks). Three were withdrawn becaus
e of worsening cardiac failure unrelated to their exercise participati
on (4, 4, 8 weeks), and one had a non-fatal cardiac arrest while shopp
ing (16 weeks). Gains of cardiorespiratory function plateaued at 16-26
weeks, with 10-15% improvement in six-minute walk, peak power output,
and peak oxygen intake linked to gains in oxygen pulse and ventilator
y threshold and reductions in resting heart rate. Marked improvements
in quality of life followed a parallel course. Conclusions-Aerobic tra
ining is safe and beneficial in compensated chronic heart failure. Gai
ns in aerobic function and quality of life persisted over a programme
lasting 52 weeks.