EMOTIONAL, NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL, AND ORGANIC FACTORS - THEIR USE IN THEPREDICTION OF PERSISTING POSTCONCUSSION SYMPTOMS AFTER MODERATE AND MILD HEAD-INJURIES
Ns. King, EMOTIONAL, NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL, AND ORGANIC FACTORS - THEIR USE IN THEPREDICTION OF PERSISTING POSTCONCUSSION SYMPTOMS AFTER MODERATE AND MILD HEAD-INJURIES, Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry, 61(1), 1996, pp. 75-81
Background-After mild and moderate bead injuries a range of postconcus
sion symptoms (PCS) are often reported by patients. Both organic and p
sychogenic factors can contribute to these. Full recovery from PCS usu
ally occurs within three months of the injury. A significant minority,
however, continue to experience symptoms beyond this time. To date, n
o means of identifying these patients early after injury has been repo
rted. This study investigates whether a combination of neuropsychologi
cal, emotional, and traditional measures of severity of head injury ta
ken early after the injury can help predict severity of FCS three mont
hs after injury. Methods-50 patients with mild or moderate head injury
had a range of measures administered at 7-10 days after injury. These
included three tests of divided attention, a PCS rating scale-the Riv
ermead postconcussion symptoms questionnaire (RPQ), the hospital anxie
ty and depression scale (BADS), the impact of event scale (IES), and p
ost-traumatic amnesia. An RPQ was then completed by all patients three
months after injury. Results-Stepwise multiple regression analysis wa
s performed with the RPQ score at three months as the dependent measur
e. A combination of eight of the scores from the early measures gave a
multiple correlation coefficient of R = 0.86 accounting for 74% of th
e variance in RPQ scores. The most predictive individual measures were
the HADS and IES. Regression analysis with RPQ score at 7-10 days as
dependent measure showed that 10 of the scores gave a coefficient of R
= 0.84 accounting for 71% of the variance. Conclusions-A combination
of measures may significantly aid the prediction of persistent PCS. Fi
ve measures: HADS, post-traumatic amnesia, SOMC, PASAT, and RPQ are re
commended for their predictive value and clinical utility. Independent
cross validation studies are required before these results can be gen
erally applied. They do, however, provide valuable indications regardi
ng those measures that are most likely to demonstrate utility.