K. Humphreys et Rh. Moos, REDUCED SUBSTANCE-ABUSE-RELATED HEALTH-CARE COSTS AMONG VOLUNTARY PARTICIPANTS IN ALCOHOLICS-ANONYMOUS, Psychiatric services, 47(7), 1996, pp. 709-713
Objective: This study examined differences in outcomes, alcoholism tre
atment utilization, and costs between alcoholic individuals with no pr
evious treatment history who chose to attend Alcoholics Anonymous (AA)
or to seek help from a professional outpatient alcoholism treatment p
rovider. Methods: Participants in this three-year prospective study we
re recruited at alcoholism information and referral services and at de
toxification units in the San Francisco Bay Area. Chi square and t tes
ts and repeated-measures analyses of variance were used to examine dat
a gathered from interviews with 201 participants at baseline and at on
e and three years. Results: At baseline, participants who chose to att
end AA meetings (N=135) were not significantly different from those wh
o chose professional outpatient treatment (N=66) in sex, marital statu
s, employment, race, and symptoms of alcohol dependence and depression
. However, AA attendees had lower incomes and less education and exper
ienced more adverse consequences of drinking at baseline than did thos
e who sought outpatient care, suggesting somewhat worse prognoses for
the AA group. Over the three-year study, per-person treatment costs fo
r the AA group were 45 percent (or $1,826) lower than costs for the ou
tpatient treatment group. Despite the lower costs, outcomes for the AA
group at both one and three years were similar to those of the outpat
ient treatment group. Conclusions: Voluntary AA participation may sign
ificantly reduce professional treatment costs. Clinicians, researchers
, and policymakers should recognize the potential health care cost off
sets offered by AA and other self-help organizations.