Rh. Kelly et al., SOIL ORGANIC-MATTER AND NUTRIENT AVAILABILITY RESPONSES TO REDUCED PLANT INPUTS IN SHORTGRASS STEPPE, Ecology, 77(8), 1996, pp. 2516-2527
We examined soil organic matter (SOM) dynamics in a shortgrass steppe
ecosystem along spatial gradients in plant inputs and temporal gradien
ts in disturbance age because a better understanding of decay characte
ristics of SOM pools may improve our ability to predict ecosystem resp
onses ra perturbation. We assessed measurable pools of SOM that are th
ought to correspond to active, intermediate, and passive SOM based upo
n turnover characteristics in three separate experiments. In a first,
we evaluated SOM pools along a spatial gradient in plant inputs, from
locations under individual bunch grasses to natural areas of plant rem
oval (ant mounds). In a second experiment we assessed SOM pools across
a temporal gradient in ant mounds ranging from approximate to 5 to 60
yr old. Finally, we compared our results from the second experiment t
o a single human-induced plant-removal experiment. We found that reduc
ed root biomass accounted for up to 90% of the variation in SOM across
our spatial gradients. In our examination of temporal dynamics of SOM
, we found that locations with little or no plant inputs for approxima
te to 45 yr had 28% less total soil C than in native areas with averag
e plant cover. We measured the greatest proportional losses (48-78%) o
f SOM in response to reduced plant inputs (over 30-60 yr) in the activ
e SOM as indexed by C and N mineralization and microbial biomass C and
N. The range of losses from intermediate organic matter as indexed by
particulate organic matter (POM) ranged from 38 to 73%, and losses fr
om the passive pool were proportionately lower (57%). Though this gene
ral pattern follows the course predicted by theory, and our measuremen
ts of turnover of intermediate SOM agree closely with models, results
indicate a considerably slower turnover rate for the active pool and a
considerably faster rate for the passive pool than expected. We compa
red our field estimates of plant-removal-induced SOM losses to simulat
ion modeling results and cultivation studies. Our comparison of field
results to Century model simulations indicated a possible model overes
timation of the impact of plant removal on SOM loss. By comparing our
plant-removal results to studies of cultivation-induced losses of SOM
on the shortgrass steppe, we found that plant-removal is not as severe
a disturbance as cropping, likely as a result of physical disturbance
s associated with tillage such as surface erosion and disturbance of s
oil aggregate structure.