The HeH2+ molecular ion decays by an electronic dipole transition from
its bound first excited state (2p sigma) to the repulsive ground stat
e (1s sigma). We have calculated the mean lifetimes of the vibrational
states of a few HeH2+ isotopes and found a large isotopic effect, in
particular for highly excited vibrational states, i.e., states with th
e same nu have different decay rates. The measured decay curves of (He
H2+)-He-4, (HeD2+)-He-3, and (HeD2+)-He-4 ( i.e., the number of HeH2molecular ions as a function of their flight time from the target cell
where they were formed), in contrast, are similar to each other. The
lack of a measurable isotopic effect is related to the HeH2+ creation
mechanism. In the charge-stripping collisions, a distribution of vibra
tional states is populated by vertical transitions and is thus centere
d around roughly the same vibrational energy and not around the same q
uantum number nu. The mean lifetimes of the different isotopes as a fu
nction of their energy are surprisingly similar to each other, therefo
re washing out the isotopic effect.