Grazing usually increases the relative growth rate (RGR) of plants. Ho
wever, it is not clear under which conditions this will result in a po
sitive effect on primary productivity. We tested the hypothesis that t
he effect of grazing on community productivity depends on the level of
competition between grazed and neighboring ungrazed plants, and that
the level and outcome of that competition depends on the size of the g
razed patch. The hypothesis predicts that as the size of a grazed patc
h increases, the area of influence of the neighboring plants becomes l
ess important in relation to the area of the patch. Thus, grazing will
more likely increase the productivity of large patches. We performed
two field experiments in a grassland community of the Flooding Pampa,
Argentina under two different weather conditions (non-flooded year and
flooded year). We analyzed the productivity of undefoliated patches,
defoliated patches of different sizes, and a neighboring area around t
he defoliated patches. We found that (1) the effect of defoliation on
productivity was affected by patch size: defoliation had neutral to po
sitive effects on intermediate and large patches and negative effects
on very small patches, and (2) defoliation had no effect on the produc
tivity of the area surrounding the defoliated patches. Our results als
o suggest that flooding limits the ability of plants to compensate for
tissue removal.