Novel Madin Darby Canine Kidney cell clones were isolated. These cell
clones exhibit differential responsiveness to inducers of tubule or cy
st formation in collagen gel culture: hepatocyte growth factor or indu
cers of intracellular cAMP formation, respectively. In gel culture, cl
one OR93.22.D6 forms cysts and responds with morphological transformat
ion to both hepatocyte growth factor and prostaglandin E(1), and is mo
st typical of a previously described cell type except for its higher t
ransepithelial electrical resistance. OR55.25.II20 forms tubules in cu
lture, is unresponsive to hepatocyte growth factor, and forms prostagl
andin-induced spherical cysts. OR55.28.V2 forms dense cell spheres und
er control conditions, is induced to form tubules by hepatocyte growth
factor, and is unresponsive to prostaglandin. OR55.29 forms only cyst
s, and is the only clone to form domes in monolayer culture. Tubule fo
rmation induced by hepatocyte growth factor, in all clones except OR55
.25.II20, is blocked by a neutralizing antibody. In defined medium, wi
thout hepatocyte growth factor or prostaglandin, OR55.25.II20 forms sp
ontaneous tubules. This finding indicates that a tubulogenic serum fac
tor is not responsible for the observed phenotype. Increasing prostagl
andin concentrations lead to inhibition of tubule formation and increa
sed cyst formation. This observation suggests that induction of intrac
ellular cAMP formation negatively regulates tubule formation in these
cells, and implies that cystogenesis may represent a ''default pathway
'' for impaired tubulogenesis. These observations demonstrate that som
e facets of renal tubulogenesis may be independent of hepatocyte growt
h factor, and that care must be exercised when comparing biological st
udies utilizing different clones.