POWER AND POLITICAL COORDINATION IN AMERICAN AND GERMAN MULTICHAMBER LEGISLATION

Citation
T. Konig et T. Brauninger, POWER AND POLITICAL COORDINATION IN AMERICAN AND GERMAN MULTICHAMBER LEGISLATION, Journal of theoretical politics, 8(3), 1996, pp. 331-360
Citations number
44
Categorie Soggetti
Political Science
ISSN journal
09516298
Volume
8
Issue
3
Year of publication
1996
Pages
331 - 360
Database
ISI
SICI code
0951-6298(1996)8:3<331:PAPCIA>2.0.ZU;2-N
Abstract
Power in American and German multi-chamber legislation is determined e ither by an inter-institutional or an internal coalition problem of al l interlinked chambers. Hence, the complexity of multi-chamber systems relies on different subgames, different types of decision rules and d ifferent types of actors. Since collective actors such as parliaments or parliamentary chambers may not act as unitary actors, we examine th e power distribution in both types of multi-chamber legislation by a g ame-theoretical method with regard to institutional settings and speci fic legislative schemes. We argue that the Shapley index is the most a ppropriate method for the comparative analysis of multi-chamber power. Our 'parallel' research strategy is, thus, based on individual and co rporate Shapley power shares which are subsequently added to collectiv e chamber power. Our comparison of American and German legislation sta rts with an analysis of two-chamber parliamentary bargaining. Whereas this application corresponds to the bicameral parliamentary decision s tage of conciliation and amending, our second application of Policy Le adership studies the checks-and-balances of all executive and legislat ive chamber actors. A third application is related to the situation of unified and divided government, and here we examine the power effects of institutional settings and party-oriented strategies in both types of multichamber legislation. In Germany, unified government excludes opposition actors, whereas American unified and divided government ref ers to the president's role in multi-chamber legislation.