Ja. Baker et al., SR-ND-PB ISOTOPIC AND TRACE-ELEMENT EVIDENCE FOR CRUSTAL CONTAMINATION OF PLUME-DERIVED FLOOD BASALTS - OLIGOCENE FLOOD VOLCANISM IN WESTERN YEMEN, Geochimica et cosmochimica acta, 60(14), 1996, pp. 2559-2581
Oligocene flood basalts from western Yemen have a relatively limited r
ange in initial isotopic composition compared with other continental f
lood basalts: Sr-87/Sr-86 = 0.70365-0.70555; Nd-143/Nd-144 = 0.51292-0
.51248 (is an element of(Nd) = +6.0 to -2.4); Pb-206/Pb-204 = 17.9-19.
3. Most compositions lie outside the isotopic ranges of temporally and
spatially appropriate mantle source compositions observed in this are
a, i.e., Red Sea/Gulf of Aden MORE mantle, the Afar plume, and Pan-Afr
ican lithospheric mantle. Correlations between indices of fractionatio
n, silica, and isotope ratios suggest that crustal contamination has s
ubstantially modified the primary isotopic and incompatible trace elem
ent characteristics of the flood basalts. However, significant scatter
in these correlations was produced by: (a) the heterogeneous isotopic
composition of Pan-African crust; (b) the difference in susceptibilit
y of magmas to contamination as a result of variable incompatible trac
e element contents in primary melts produced by differing degrees of p
artial melting; (c) the presence or absence of plagioclase as a fracti
onating phase generating complex contamination trajectories for Sr; (d
) sampling over a wide area not representing a single coherent magmati
c system; and (e) variation in contamination mechanisms from assimilat
ion associated with fractionation (AFC) to assimilation by hot mafic m
agmas with little concomitant fractionation. The presence of plagiocla
se as a fractionating phase in some suites that were undergoing AFC re
quires assimilation to have taken place within the crust and, coupled
with the limited LREE-enrichment accompanying isotopic variations, exc
ludes the possibility that an AFC-type process took place during magma
transfer through the lithospheric mantle. Isotopic compositions of so
me of the inferred crustal assimilants are similar to those postulated
by other workers for an enriched lithospheric mantle source of many f
lood basalts in southwestern Yemen, Ethiopia, and Djibouti. The wester
n Yemen flood basalts contain 0-30% crust which largely swamps their p
rimary lead isotopic signature, but the primary Sr-Nd isotopic signatu
re is close to that of the least contaminated and isotopically most de
pleted flood basalts. LREE/HFSE and LILE/HFSE ratios also correlate wi
th isotopic data as a result of crustal contamination. However, Nb/La
and K/Nb ratios of >1.1 and <150, respectively, in least contaminated
samp!es require an OIB-like source. The pre-contamination isotopic sig
nature is estimated to be: Sr-87/Sr-86 approximate to 0.7036; Nd-143/N
d-144 approximate to 0.51292; Pb-206/Pb-204 approximate to 18.4-19.0.
This, coupled with low LILE/HFSE ratios, suggest the source has charac
teristics akin to the Afar plume. A mantle source isotopically more de
pleted than Bulk Earth, but not as depleted as MORE, coupled with LILE
depletion, also characterises other examples of plume-derived flood v
olcanism. This mantle reservoir is responsible for the second largest
outbursts of volcanism on Earth and has radiogenic isotopic characteri
stics akin to PREMA mantle, but the incompatible trace element signatu
re of HIMU mantle.