Am. Keenan et Tm. Bach, VIDEO ASSESSMENT OF REARFOOT MOVEMENTS DURING WALKING - A RELIABILITYSTUDY, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation, 77(7), 1996, pp. 651-655
Objective: Rearfoot motion, particularly rearfoot pronation, has been
associated with many foot and leg pathologies. The assessment of abnor
mal rearfoot pronation frequently involves the use of video assessment
in both clinical and research settings, but the reliability of this a
ssessment has not been addressed. Design: In this study, 14 participan
ts were videotaped during walking. Five clinicians individually viewed
the recordings on two separate occasions and assessed whether the par
ticipant's rearfoot motion was abnormal. Setting: University Gait Anal
ysis Laboratory. Patients or Other Participants: Patients from the uni
versity's podiatry clinic were assessed for rearfoot motion by five ex
perienced clinicians. Intervention: Because this was a reliability stu
dy, no intervention was undertaken. Main Outcome Measures: Clinicians
were asked to assess the videotape of the patients walking and indicat
e on a 5-point scale if they considered the person to be abnormally pr
onating. Retest and intertester results were compared. Results: The re
sults indicated that there was poor intertester agreement (kappa = .19
). Retest agreement, while slightly higher, varied from poor to fair (
kappa = -.12 to kappa = .59). Conclusions: Although video recordings h
ave been thought to enhance reliability of assessment of rearfoot mori
on, the results indicated that the exclusive use of video recordings i
n the assessment of motion of the rearfoot was not reliable. (C) 1996
by the American Congress of Rehabilitation Medicine and the American A
cademy of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation