Wd. Crill et al., WITHIN-GENERATION AND BETWEEN-GENERATION EFFECTS OF TEMPERATURE ON THE MORPHOLOGY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF DROSOPHILA-MELANOGASTER, Evolution, 50(3), 1996, pp. 1205-1218
We investigated the effects of developmental and parental temperatures
on several physiological and morphological traits of adult Drosophila
melanogaster. Flies for the parental generation were raised at either
low or moderate temperature (18 degrees C or 25 degrees C) and then m
ated in the four possible sex-by-parental temperature crosses. Their o
ffspring were raised at either 18 degrees C or 25 degrees C and then s
cored as adults for morphological (dry body mass, wing size, and abdom
inal melanization [females only]), physiological (knock-down temperatu
re, and thermal dependence of walking speed), and life history (egg si
ze) traits. The experiment was replicated, and the factorial design al
lows us to determine whether and how paternal, maternal, and developme
ntal temperatures (as well as offspring sex) influence the various tra
its. Sex and developmental temperature had major effects on all traits
. Females had larger bodies and wings, higher knock-down temperatures,
and slower speeds (but similar shaped performance curves) than males.
Development at 25 degrees C (versus at 18 degrees C) increased knock-
down temperature, increased maximal speed and thermal performance brea
dth, decreased the optimal temperature for walking, decreased body mas
s and wing size, reduced abdominal melanization, and reduced egg size.
Parental temperatures influenced a few traits, but the effects were g
enerally small relative to those of sex or developmental temperature.
Flies whose mother had been raised at 25 degrees C (versus at 18 degre
es C) had slightly higher knock-down temperature and smaller body mass
. Flies whose father had been raised at 25 degrees C had relatively lo
nger wings. The effects of paternal, maternal, and developmental tempe
ratures sometimes differed in direction. The existence of significant
within- and between-generation effects suggests that comparative studi
es need to standardize thermal environments for at least two generatio
ns, that attempts to estimate ''field'' heritabilities may be unreliab
le for some traits, and that predictions of short-term evolutionary re
sponses to selection will be difficult.