S. Harter et al., THE PERCEIVED DIRECTIONALITY OF THE LINK BETWEEN APPROVAL AND SELF-WORTH - THE LIABILITIES OF A LOOKING-GLASS SELF-ORIENTATION AMONG YOUNG ADOLESCENTS, Journal of research on adolescence, 6(3), 1996, pp. 285-308
This study examined three orientations toward the relation between pee
r approval and global self-worth among young adolescents: (a) Self-wor
th is based upon peer approval of the self, a looking glass self-orien
tation; (b) self-worth is viewed as preceding approval from others; an
d (c) no connection is reported between self-worth and peer approval.
A number of liabilities of a looking glass self-orientation were hypot
hesized and supported by the findings. Participants basing their self-
worth on peer approval reported the greatest preoccupation with peer a
pproval, they were most likely to be distracted from their schoolwork
by peers (according to teachers' reports), they perceived the greatest
fluctuations in both classmate approval and their self-worth, and the
y reported lower levels of classmate approval (confirmed by teachers)
and self-worth, compared to those reporting that self-worth precedes a
pproval. Findings were discussed in terms of the need for a model that
will elucidate the precursors of these three orientations and their c
orrelates.