Jp. Donovan et al., EFFICACY OF IMMUNOTHERAPY TO RAGWEED ANTIGEN TESTED BY CONTROLLED ANTIGEN EXPOSURE, Annals of allergy, asthma, & immunology, 77(1), 1996, pp. 74-80
Background: Immunotherapy is a recognized component in the management
of allergic rhinitis. Its efficacy has been evaluated in a number of c
linical field trials. These methods of evaluation are limited by contr
ol of antigen exposure. Objective: A study was designed to evaluate th
e efficacy of immunotherapy in ragweed-induced rhinoconjunctivitis usi
ng an environmental exposure unit. Methods: Forty-three subjects were
grouped into (1) immunotherapy group: ragweed-allergic subjects on mai
ntenance ragweed immunotherapy for at least 2 years (N = 16), (2) posi
tive control group: ragweed-allergic subjects who had never received i
mmunotherapy (n = 16), and (3) negative control group: ragweed-nonalle
rgic subjects (N = 11). Ragweed specific skin tests and ragweed IgE le
vels were obtained prior to exposure. The study was done in a room whe
re levels of 2,500 to 3,000 grains m(3) of ragweed were maintained ove
r three hours. Symptoms were recorded every 15 minutes. Results: Nasal
symptoms in the immunotherapy group were significantly less than in t
he positive control group after 45 minutes (P = .025). Significant dif
ferences were not observed for ocular symptoms. Combined nasal and ocu
lar scores were 50% less in the immunotherapy group than in the positi
ve control group by 75 minutes (P = .039). Ragweed-specific skin tests
and IgE were significantly less in the immunotherapy group than in th
e positive control group. Rhinoconjunctivitis symptoms in the negative
control group were absent throughout. Conclusions: Controlled ragweed
pollen exposure in this setting demonstrated that ragweed immunothera
py significantly reduced symptoms of ragweed-allergic rhinitis but had
no significant effect on ocular symptoms, This system presents opport
unities for additional studies on immunotherapy for allergic respirato
ry conditions.