Wa. Deboer et Gnj. Tytgat, HOW TO TREAT HELICOBACTER-PYLORI INFECTION - SHOULD TREATMENT STRATEGIES BE BASED ON TESTING BACTERIAL SUSCEPTIBILITY - A PERSONAL VIEWPOINT, European journal of gastroenterology & hepatology, 8(7), 1996, pp. 709-716
Peptic ulcer disease is an infectious disease. Only antibiotic regimen
s that achieve a 90% cure should be used to treat this infection. Anti
microbial susceptibility is the main determinant in the success of the
rapy; cure rates are usually lower in resistant strains. As in any oth
er infectious disease it is essential in treatment studies to stratify
results according to pretreatment bacterial susceptibility. Cure-rate
s have to be reported separately for sensitive and resistant strains.
It must be realized that a study achieving a high cure rate with a cer
tain regimen can either have included few patients with resistant stra
ins or, alternatively, the regimen tested can have a high efficacy in
resistant strains. This issue is fundamental and only if that informat
ion is available, do we know whether or not we can reproduce the resul
ts reported in that particular study in a different population. We hav
e reviewed all Helicobacter studies that tested pretreatment bacterial
susceptibility. The results achieved with dual therapy, bismuth tripl
e therapy, proton pump inhibitor triple therapy and quadruple therapy
in sensitive and resistant strains are discussed. Based on these data,
treatment recommendations are made for empirical treatment in areas w
ith low resistance rates and those with high resistance rates. If trea
tment is individualized and based on the antibiogram then easier, shor
ter and cheaper regimens seem possible.