H. Strik, EFFECTS OF BANDWIDTH ON GLOTTAL AIR-FLOW WAVE-FORMS ESTIMATED BY INVERSE FILTERING - COMMENTS, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 100(2), 1996, pp. 1246-1249
In the subject paper [Alku and Vilkman, J. Acoust. Sec. Am. 98, 763-76
7 (1995); hence AV], AV describe the results of their research on the
effect of bandwidth on estimated voice source parameters. They found t
hat reducing the bandwidth (by low-pass filtering the glottal flow sig
nals) leads to a distortion of the estimated parameters. Although I do
agree that low-pass filtering influences the estimate of the voice so
urce parameters, I do not agree with some of their conclusions, explan
ations, and recommendations. Furthermore, the method they used does no
t seem to be optimal for the purpose of their research. These matters
are discussed in this Letter. (C) 1996 Acoustical Society of America.