Fc. Arnett et al., INCREASED PREVALENCE OF SYSTEMIC-SCLEROSIS IN A NATIVE-AMERICAN TRIBEIN OKLAHOMA - ASSOCIATION WITH AN AMERINDIAN HLA HAPLOTYPE, Arthritis and rheumatism, 39(8), 1996, pp. 1362-1370
Objective. To investigate a high prevalence of systemic sclerosis (SSc
; scleroderma) in a well-defined population of 21,255 Choctaw Indians
residing in 8 southeastern Oklahoma counties who were ''users'' of Ind
ian Health Services, Methods. A case-control study of 12 SSc cases and
48 matched non-SSc controls (4 per case) was conducted to investigate
potential occupational, residential, and infectious exposures, as wel
l as genetic factors which might predispose to SSc, HLA class II allel
es were determined by DNA oligotyping, and class I and III alleles wer
e defined serologically. Results, The prevalence of SSc in full-bloode
d Choctaws was at least 8/1,704, or 469/100,000 (95% confidence interv
al [95% CI] 203-930) over the 4-year interval 1990-1994 and was signif
icantly higher than that among non-full-blooded Choctaws (6/19,551, or
31/100,000) (P = 0.00001, odds ratio [OR] = 15.4, 95% CP 4.9-49.8), T
he overall prevalence of SSc in Oklahoma Choctaws (66/100,000) also wa
s significantly higher than that in other Native Americans in Oklahoma
(9.5/100,000) (P = 10(-6), OR = 6.95, 95% CI 3.3-13.7), who showed a
prevalence similar to that reported for whites (2.1-25.3/100,000). Amo
ng the SSc cases, there was striking homogeneity of disease expression
with the majority exhibiting diffuse scleroderma, pulmonary fibrosis,
and autoantibodies to topoisomerase I, No environmental exposures wer
e found to be in excess among cases versus controls, The strongest ris
k factor for SSc in cases (100%) versus controls (54%) was an HLA hapl
otype bearing the alleles B35, Cw4, DRB11602 (DR2), DQA1*0501, and DQ
B10301 (DQ7) (P = 0.002, P-corr = 0.036, OR = 21, 95% CI 2.9-437), Su
rvey of another group of Choctaws residing in another state revealed n
o cases of SSc despite a high frequency of the same BLA haplotype, Con
clusion, Full-blooded Choctaw Native Americans living in southeastern
Oklahoma have the highest prevalence of SSc yet found in any populatio
n, A major risk factor for disease is a uniquely Amerindian HLA haplot
ype; however, additional genes and/or an as-yet-unidentified environme
ntal exposure seem likely.