Hl. Swanson et Vw. Berninger, INDIVIDUAL-DIFFERENCES IN CHILDRENS WRITING - A FUNCTION OF WORKING-MEMORY OR READING OR BOTH PROCESSES, Reading & writing, 8(4), 1996, pp. 357-383
The purpose of this study was to investigate whether a general or spec
ific working memory (WM) system is related to writing and whether indi
vidual differences in reading and/or processing efficiency underlie th
e correlations between WM and writing. Two studies correlated WM with
writing (Test of Written Language-TOWL) and reading measures. In Study
1, WM was correlated significantly with a number of writing measures,
particularly to those measures related to text generation. Working-me
mory also contributed unique variance to writing, beyond what is predi
cted by reading comprehension. Study 2 compared the correlations of ve
rbal and visual-spatial WM measures with the TOWL under initial and en
hanced memory processing (dynamic assessment) conditions. The coeffici
ents were statistically comparable between initial and enhanced proces
sing conditions, suggesting that individual differences in processing
efficiency do nor account for the correlations between WM and writing.
Overall, the results indicated that (a) WM measures contribute unique
variance to writing, especially text generation, and (b) working memo
ry performance improves under gain conditions, but this enhanced proce
ssing efficiency did not appear to mediate the links between WM and wr
iting. Taken together, the two studies support a general capacity expl
anation for the relationship between working memory and text generatio
n.