Cholinergic deficiency was postulated to play an important role in the
mental decline observed in Alzheimer's (AD), Parkinson's (PD) and mul
tiinfarct (MID) dementia. In the present study, 11 AD, 8 MID and 7 FD
patients (DSM III-R diagnostic criteria for dementia) and 9 healthy ag
e-matched controls (CTRL) were given IV 0.5 mg scopolamine (SCO) or pl
acebo (PLA) in random order (double blind) within one week. The Hebrew
Short Mental Test (SMT) and Wechsler Memory Scale (WMS) were administ
ered before and after SCO and PLA in each patient. A comparison of SCO
vs. PLA utilizing MANCOVA (the covariate being the basal mental perfo
rmance [BAS] with SMT or WMS) showed that SCO affected all the groups
similarly, except for the Wechsler subtest of logic memory which showe
d larger deterioration in CTRL compared to demented patients. ANOVA an
d MANCOVA analyses did not distinguish between the three demented grou
ps. SCO administration does not differentiate between demented patient
s and CTRL and does not enable discrimination between patients with AD
, MID and PD. Moreover, some CTRL with still normal cognitive performa
nce, but lower BAS may be more vulnerable to SCO than others. The inte
grity of the cholinergic system may be responsible for the different s
ensitivity to SCO challenge.