Ga. Peterson et al., PRECIPITATION USE EFFICIENCY AS AFFECTED BY CROPPING AND TILLAGE SYSTEMS, Journal of production agriculture, 9(2), 1996, pp. 180-186
Water is the driving variable in Great Plains agriculture and sustaina
bility depends on efficient use of incident precipitation. Spring and
winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L.)-fallow (SWF and WWF) farming syste
ms, as currently practiced, are not economically sustainable without g
overnment subsidies. This paper synthesizes information regarding the
water use efficiency (WUE) of intensified cropping systems in cultivat
ed dryland agroecosystems and proposes solutions to ensure sustainabli
ty. Decreasing tillage and maintaining crop residue on the soil is req
uisite to improved efficiency. No-till fallow efficiency, the percenta
ge of the precipitation stored during fallow, reached 40% in the early
1970s. However, scientists in the 1980s and 1990s still report fallow
efficiencies no greater than 40%, indicating that other major system
changes must occur if progress is to continue. Residue levels in the G
reat Plains usually are < 3 tons/acre and this probably has capped fal
low efficiency near 40%. No-till management of crop residues after spr
ing or winter wheat harvest increases soil water storage in the first
portion of the fallow (July to May) compared with conventional fallow
management, but the soil in the late fallow period (June to September
for winter wheat and June to May for spring wheat) gains no more water
, and may even lose water relative to the quantity present in the spri
ng. Overall system efficiency is best evaluated by calculating grain W
UE values. Modern no-till wheat-fallow (WF) systems, even with maximum
fallow efficiencies, only had average grain WUE of 104 lb/acre per in
. for spring wheat and 140 lb/acre per in. for winter wheat. WUE for 3
-yr cropping systems, like winter wheat-corn (Zea mays L.)-fallow or w
inter wheat-sorghum [Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench]-fallow, increased WU
E in Central and Southern Great Plains. Three year system WUE averaged
180 lb/acre per in., a 28% increase compared with WF. In the Northern
Plains, continuous spring wheat systems averaged 122 lb/acre per in.,
a 15% increase compared with SWF. Individual crops within systems had
the following potential WUE values: corn = 245 lb/acre per in., grain
sorghum = 225 lb/acre per in., prose millet (Panicum miliaceum L). =
195 lb/acre per in., spring wheat = 216 lb/acre per in., and winter wh
eat = 150 lb/acre per in. Maximum system efficiency depends on choosin
g the most efficient plants for a given geographic area. Intensified c
ropping systems improve our ability to use precipitation efficiently.
However, adoption of higher intensity cropping systems depends more on
economic outcomes and government programs than on WUE or environmenta
l effects.