The accuracy of 2 methods for determining germinable soil seed banks w
as compared in soil cores containing known seed loads of 5 tropical gr
asses placed on sand columns in pots. A sprayed method watered soil co
res for 30 minutes per day, and a capillary method watered cores by ca
pillary action from shallow trays. The sprayed method produced signifi
cantly (P<0.05) higher seedling emergence than the capillary method an
d gave more reliable estimates of seed load. In a second pot experimen
t, using soil cores from a grazing experiment, the sprayed method agai
n resulted in significantly (P<0.05) higher seedling emergence than th
e capillary method. We consider that the sprayed method more closely s
imulates the natural process in a field situation, where seeds are sub
jected to daily fluctuations in moisture potential rather than being c
ontinuously wet, as occurs with the capillary method.