M. Mensching et al., RISK FACTOR MODEL FOR SCHIZOPHRENIA ACCOR DING TO BRODSKY AND BRODSKY- AN EMPIRICAL-STUDY, Zeitschrift fur klinische Psychologie, Psychiatrie und Psychotherapie, 44(1), 1996, pp. 33-48
In the year 1981 the canadian psychologists Patricia & Marvin Brodsky
published an article about a model integrating risk variables involved
in the development of Schizophrenia which is very important but not v
ery well known in the german speaking countries. This model which desc
ribes essentially the interaction of four risk variables, such as ment
al health of the mother, neonatal status, temperament and mothering st
yle, shall be published for the interested reader on the one hand. On
the other hand the consequences of the risk variable ''mothering style
'' should be empirically examined in a retrospective study. With a sta
ndardized interview containing all essential variables of Brodsky's ri
sk model 73 patients suffering in schizophrenia and being inpatient in
the Rheinische Landesklinik Bonn were examined and the interview data
were evaluated with regard to the contents in contrast to a control g
roup of 26 healthy persons. With regard to the ''schizophrenia spectru
m'' the portion of so called ''superphrenics'' (defined as ''artistica
lly and musically gifted offspring with a schizophrenic mother'') was
not significantly increased in the schizophrenic sample (17,8% vs 7,7%
) but the comparison of mothering style (empathic contingent vs. non-e
mpathic and non-contingent) revealed a statistically significant diffe
rence between the groups. Finally the data of the risk variable ''moth
ering style'' are discussed in the light of the Brodsky-model and it i
s pointed at the special problems in reliable and valid operationalisa
tion and assessment of the risk variables.