We retrospectively reviewed 57 open patella fractures treated at our i
nstitution between 1976 and 1989. Forty-four patients with 47 fracture
s (cases) were available for follow-up a mean of 9.4 years after injur
y (range 2.2-15.7). High-energy vehicular trauma was the cause of inju
ry in >90% of cases. Treatment included osteosynthesis in 50% of cases
and patellectomy (partial or total) in the remainder. At follow-up ev
aluation, results were excellent in 17% of cases, good in 60%, fair in
17%, and poor in 6%. Nonunion occurred in two cases in which nonrigid
internal fixation was used. The incidence of deep infection was 10.7%
, and the infection rate correlated with the magnitude of soft-tissue
injury. Two of the seven fractures (29%) treated with cerclage wiring
became infected. None of the open type I and II fractures treated with
immediate internal fixation or primary wound closure (or both) became
infected. Therefore, we recommend immediate rigid internal fixation (
other than cerclage wiring) of types I and II open patella fractures.
Partial patellectomy of highly comminuted fractures provided results s
imilar to those of internal fixation of less comminuted fractures. Thu
s, when comminution precludes fixation, partial patellectomy can be pe
rformed without hesitation. The timing of wound closure should be indi
vidualized.