D. Zillmann et al., EFFECTS OF EXEMPLIFICATION IN NEWS REPORTS ON THE PERCEPTION OF SOCIAL-ISSUES, Journalism and mass communication quarterly, 73(2), 1996, pp. 427-444
A news report on the plight of a minority of American family farmers w
as manipulated to create versions differing in the degree of precision
of general information (precise, imprecise) and in the use of exempli
fying case histories (selective, blended, representative). Selective e
xemplification featured only histories of failing farms, representativ
e exemplification a distribution of histories of failing and successfu
l farms proportional to their actual occurrence. Respondents reported
their own views concerning the farmers' plight either shortly after re
ading or after a delay of one or two weeks. The accuracy of estimates
of failing farms was found to be highest for representative and lowest
for selective exemplification - despite the availability of correctiv
e general information. These effects were stable over time.