ROLE OF INTERSTITIAL BRACHYTHERAPY IN ORAL AND OROPHARYNGEAL CARCINOMA - REFLECTION OF A SERIES OF 1344 PATIENTS TREATED AT THE TIME OF INITIAL PRESENTATION
M. Pernot et al., ROLE OF INTERSTITIAL BRACHYTHERAPY IN ORAL AND OROPHARYNGEAL CARCINOMA - REFLECTION OF A SERIES OF 1344 PATIENTS TREATED AT THE TIME OF INITIAL PRESENTATION, Otolaryngology and head and neck surgery, 115(6), 1996, pp. 519-526
Our study focuses on a series of 1344 cases of carcinoma of the oral c
avity and oropharynx treated between 1973 and 1992. Brachytherapy was
always performed with iridium 192, either alone or in combination with
external-beam irradiation or with surgery for the treatment of the pr
imary tumor. For the oral cavity, we studied 565 cases of mobile tongu
e, The local control and overall survival rates, respectively, at 5 ye
ars are as follows: for T1, 92% and 70%; for T2, 62% and 42%; and for
T3, 50% and 29%. For the subgroup T1T2N0, there was a better prognosis
for treatment by brachytherapy of the primary lesion alone (p < 0.000
1), Two hundred seven cases of floor-of-mouth carcinoma have been repo
rted, The T3T4 patients were not considered surgical candidates. The l
ocal control and overall survival rates, respectively, at 5 years are
as follows: for T1, 97% and 71%; for T2, 72% and 42%; and for T3, 51%
and 35%, Ninety-seven patients were treated by postoperative brachythe
rapy, These were patients for whom the margins after surgery were posi
tive or narrow, A technique termed the modified bridge is described fo
r lesions located in the mandible, Carcinomas of the buccal mucosa are
rare in our country; only 42 cases were treated in this comparison of
two techniques, and the overall survival rate was 48%, Epidermoid car
cinomas of the oropharynx have nearly always been treated by a combina
tion of external-beam irradiation and brachytherapy because of the bil
ateral node risk, Seventy-two patients with epidermoid cancers of the
base of the tongue had an overall survival rate of 44%, The tonsil, so
ft palate, and pillars benefited from the use of the loop technique of
brachytherapy combined with external-beam irradiation, Three hundred
sixty-one patients were treated, Among these patients were two groups
with different prognoses, Patients with tonsil, soft palate, and poste
rior pillar carcinomas had a local control rate of 84% and an overall
survival rate of 57%, Conversely, the anterior pillar and the pharyngo
glossal sulcus have a local control rate of only 65% and an overall su
rvival rate of 38%. Statistical analysis revealed the prognostic facto
rs for local control. The complications were classified into four grad
es: minor (20%), moderate (9%), major (4%), or inducing death (0.2%),
The bone complications of grade 2 or 3 are more frequent for the floor
of the mouth than for other locations.