This paper examines the question of whether or not L2 learners have ac
cess to principles of universal grammar from the perspective of a some
what extreme learning situation. A group of German high school student
s who were exposed to English exclusively through classroom teaching w
ere tested for their ability to pass correct judgments on a set of Eng
lish structures significantly different from those of their native lan
guage. The results indicate that as a group these students fared consi
derably worse than what has been reported for other types of L2 learne
rs in the literature. This suggests that under the specific learning c
onditions of classroom teaching the students did not have access to UG
principles. However, at the individual level significant differences
between students were found. It is argued that access to universal gra
mmar is controlled both by specific aspects of the learning situation
and by an individual's mental biology.