Ca. Robbins et Pn. Breysse, THE EFFECT OF VAPOR POLARITY AND BOILING-POINT ON BREAKTHROUGH FOR BINARY-MIXTURES ON RESPIRATOR CARBON, American Industrial Hygiene Association journal, 57(8), 1996, pp. 717-723
This research evaluated the effect of the polarity of a second vapor o
n the adsorption of a polar and a nonpolar vapor using the Wheeler mod
el. To examine the effect of polarity, it was also necessary to observ
e the effect of component boiling point. The 1% breakthrough time (1%
t(b)), kinetic adsorption capacity (W-e), and rate constant (k(v)) of
the Wheeler model were determined for vapor challenges on carbon beds
for both p-xylene and pyrrole (referred to as test vapors) individuall
y, and in equimolar binary mixtures with the polar and nonpolar vapors
toluene, p-fluorotoluene, o-dichlorobenzene, and p-dichlorobenzene (r
eferred to as probe vapors). Probe vapor polarity (0 to 2.5 Debye) did
not systematically alter the 1% t(b), W-e, or k(v) of the test vapors
. The 1% t(b) and W-e for test vapors in binary mixtures can be estima
ted reasonably well, using the Wheeler model, from single-vapor data (
1% t(b) +/- 30%, W-e +/- 20%). The test vapor 1% t(b) depended mainly
on total vapor concentration in both single and binary systems. W-e wa
s proportional to test vapor fractional molar concentration (mole frac
tion) in mixtures. The k(v) for p-xylene was significantly different (
p less than or equal to 0.001) when compared according to probe boilin
g point; however; these differences were apparently of limited importa
nce in estimating 1% t(b) for the range of boiling points tested (111
to 180 degrees C). Although the polarity and boiling point of chemical
s in the range tested are not practically important in predicting 1% t
(b) with tile Wheeler model, an effect due to probe boiling point is s
uggested, and tests with chemicals of more widely ranging boiling poin
t are warranted. Since the 1% t(b), and thus, respirator service life,
depends mainly on total vapor concentration, these data underscore th
e importance of taking into account, the presence of other vapors when
estimating respirator service life for a vapor in a mixture.