The occurrence of organic-rich mudrocks overlying carbonate deposits i
n the rock record has typically been ascribed to changes in relative s
ea level. We propose, alternatively, that progressive eutrophication o
f the euphotic zone caused the ecological demise of a Late Devonian ma
rine carbonate ramp system in Alberta and its subsequent burial in org
anic-rich mudrocks. Similar lithologic transitions elsewhere in the st
ratigraphic record may also reflect eutrophication rather than major s
hifts in sea level. The transition from Upper Devonian carbonates to D
evonian-Carboniferous black mudrocks in Alberta is characterized by a
gradual decrease in net carbonate accumulation as indicated by (1) an
upward increase in mud, phosphate, and glauconite, (2) the existence o
f firmground surfaces, and (3) a change from a dominantly phototrophic
to heterotrophic benthic assemblage. An upward trend to lower 'bulk d
elta(13)C(organic) and delta(15)N values reflects the eutrophication o
f surface waters by upwelling of nutrient-laden deeper waters. Resulta
nt primary production propelled higher organic-matter flux to the sea
floor, caused the demise of carbonate-producing benthic organisms, and
promoted burial of carbonate deposits by organic-rich mudrocks.