Mh. Shapiro, ILLICIT REASONS AND MEANS FOR REPRODUCTION - ON EXCESSIVE CHOICE AND CATEGORICAL AND TECHNOLOGICAL IMPERATIVES, Hastings law journal, 47(4), 1996, pp. 1081
Professor Shapiro analyzes the modes of assisted reproduction availabl
e and the ramifications of taking advantage of these reproductive tech
niques. His analysis includes the effect of choice on individuals, mot
ivations for using reproductive technology, the Constitutionality of e
nforcing agreements surrounding reproductive technology and whether re
productive technology is an appropriate use of persons under the secon
d formulation of Kant's categorical imperative. Professor Shapiro also
addresses common criticisms of new reproductive technologies and coll
aborations (NRTCs). Professor Shapiro disagrees with broad condemnatio
ns of reproductive technology. He warns against dismissing NRTCs based
only on a fear of new technology or a preexisting impression of socie
tal norms and values without further analysis of the reproductive tech
nology. He advocates rational decision-making and a more rigorous eval
uation of each reproductive technology.