A. Pasagianmacaulay et al., URINARY MARKERS OF ESTROGEN METABOLISM 2-ALPHA-HYDROXYLATION AND 16-ALPHA-HYDROXYLATION IN PREMENOPAUSAL WOMEN, Steroids, 61(8), 1996, pp. 461-467
There is considerable scientific interest in whether measurement of th
e major estrogen metabolites 2- and 16 alpha-hydroxyestrone will shed
light on the role of estrogen in the risk of breast cancer. These have
been difficult to measure in large numbers because of the need for ra
diolabeled tracers, but a new assay is able to utilize spot urine samp
les. The main objective of this study was to assess the reliability of
a newly developed enzyme immunoassay (EIA) for the measurement of 2-
and 16 alpha-hydroxyestrone in urine samples collected from a large gr
oup of healthy premenopausal women enrolled in a clinical trial. A sec
ondary objective was to assess the impact of several factors such as b
ody weight on the urinary estrogen metabolite ratios. The study cohort
included 174 women aged 44-50, who were enrolled in the Cardiovascula
r Risk Factors and Menopause Trial, also referred to as the Women's He
althy Lifestyle Project (WHLP), an ongoing 5-year clinical trial of 53
5 premenopausal women randomized either to an intensive dietary life-s
tyle intervention group or to an assess ment-only control group. Measu
rements of 2- and 16 alpha-hydroxyestrone showed a high intraclass cor
relation for blind duplicate urine samples (R = 0.94 and R = 0.80), cr
oss-sectionally and over lime (R = 0.79 and R = 0.62), in this populat
ion of healthy premenopausal women. The intervention diet (of 25% of t
otal calories from fat) did not appear to influence the estrogen metab
olite ratio. This new estrogen metabolite EIA demonstrates good reliab
ility and thus may be appropriate for use in large epidemiologic studi
es of estrogen-related diseases. There was no relation between dietary
fat reduction, weight loss, and increased exercise and change in the
ratio among premenopausal women in this study.