Cl. Turner et Ak. Knapp, RESPONSES OF A C-4 GRASS AND 3 C-3 FORBS TO VARIATION IN NITROGEN ANDLIGHT IN TALLGRASS PRAIRIE, Ecology, 77(6), 1996, pp. 1738-1749
In tallgrass prairie, high plant species diversity results not from a
large number of grass species, but from a large number of forb (nongra
ss, herbaceous) species. Forbs exhibit morphological, life history, an
d ecophysiological characteristics that contrast sharply with those of
the dominant C-4 grasses. Success of the subdominant forbs varies str
ongly with topographic position and burning regime, and landscape scal
e patterns of abundance are well documented. But comparatively little
is known about the mechanisms determining these patterns in persistent
tallgrass prairie forbs. To elucidate these mechanisms, (1) leaf-leve
l physiological characteristics of the dominant C-4 grass, Andropogon
gerardii, and four co-occurring C-3 forbs were measured in response to
natural and experimentally manipulated gradients of N availability, a
nd (2) seasonal light environments of forbs in contrasting topographic
positions and burning regimes and their morphological and physiologic
al responses in these environments were compared to determine whether
resource availability and utilization patterns contributed to patterns
of forb distribution and abundance. The effects of burning regime and
topographic position on maximum rate of photosynthesis (A) and stomat
al conductance to water vapor (g) measured at the leaf level were not
consistent with patterns of forb abundance. Nitrogen did not appear to
limit forb physiological processes, even though increased N availabil
ity resulted in higher tissue N concentrations and greater biomass. Th
ere was no consistent increase in A or decrease in g in response to fe
rtilization. However, A at low light levels was as much as 67% higher
in fertilized Vernonia baldwinii and A. gerardii compared to unfertili
zed plants. Greater light availability to forbs in the canopy was asso
ciated with lower grass biomass production in uplands compared to lowl
ands and in unburned compared to burned sites. Forbs did not appear to
adjust morphologically (leaf area and plant height) to different ligh
t environments at different sites. As a result, as much as 90% of forb
leaf area in the burned lowland was displayed in low light, whereas a
s little as 30% of forb leaf area was in low light in the uplands at m
idseason. Estimates of potential whole-plant carbon uptake, based on l
eaf area distribution relative to available light and A as a function
of light availability, agreed well with patterns of forb abundance and
production. Differences in light availability may account for much of
the variability in forb abundance related to burning regime and topog
raphic position by limiting carbon gain in forbs more in burned lowlan
ds than in other sites.