M. Holyoak et Sp. Lawler, PERSISTENCE OF AN EXTINCTION-PRONE PREDATOR-PREY INTERACTION THROUGH METAPOPULATION DYNAMICS, Ecology, 77(6), 1996, pp. 1867-1879
In theory, predator-prey pairs with extinction-prone local populations
can persist through metapopulation dynamics, wherein local population
s fluctuate asynchronously, occasionally providing dispersers that pre
vent permanent extinction in all patches. A few studies have shown tha
t spatial structure can extend predator-prey persistence. However, no
studies have unequivocally demonstrated the asynchrony among patches,
low dispersal rates, and rescue effects that prove metapopulation dyna
mics extend persistence. We used a protist predator-prey pair to show
that spatial subdivision lengthens persistence through metapopulation
dynamics. The pair comprised the predaceous ciliate, Didinium nasutum,
feeding on the bacterivorous ciliate, Colpidium cf. striatum. A repli
cated experiment assessed how habitat subdivision affects persistence.
Undivided habitats were of four volumes: 30, 180, 270, and 750 mt. Su
bdivided microcosms, or ''arrays,'' were groups of nine or 25 linked 3
0-mL bottles (270 or 750 mt total volume). In arrays, predators and pr
ey persisted for 130 d (602 prey and 437 predator generations), at whi
ch point the experiment ended. Predators went extinct in undivided mic
rocosms of equivalent volumes within a mean of only 70 d. Predators pe
rsisted for a mean of just 19 d in isolated 30-mL bottles (equivalent
to isolated patches of arrays). In a separate experiment, prey were dr
iven extinct in four of 15 isolated 30-mL bottles, and persistence tim
es of predators were broadly similar. We documented the following hall
marks of metapopulation dynamics: (1) asynchronous fluctuations in dif
ferent subpopulations; (2) frequent local prey extinctions and recolon
izations; (3) persistence of protists in arrays, despite extinction of
isolated local populations; and (4) rescue effects in predator popula
tions. Other experiments measured dispersal rates and the effects on l
ocal dynamics of immigrant predators and prey, and initial predator :
prey ratios. Only a small fraction of protists dispersed within a gene
ration, consistent with metapopulation dynamics. Immigration of predat
ors increased the frequency of local extinctions of prey, and immigrat
ion of prey increased the persistence of both predators and prey. High
er initial predator:prey ratios decreased the persistence of prey in u
ndivided volumes. Although the pair persisted regionally in arrays, da
ta indicated that local extinctions of prey were common. In array patc
hes, predator:prey ratios were higher and predator-prey cycles were sh
orter than in undivided volumes. Dispersal made local dynamics more pr
one to extinction, yet promoted regional persistence because the risk
of extinction of distant subpopulations became independent.