To model high injection phenomena in P-N junction devices it is usuall
y necessary to use numerical analysis. This is because the standard pr
ocedure of dividing the structure into neutral zones and depletion lay
er (regional approximation) fails. In a recent paper, Yue et al. [J. A
ppl. Phys. 77, 1611 (1995)] proposed an extension of the Shockley theo
ry, retaining the form of the conventional diffusion current-only mode
l for the conduction mechanism. Their solution was based on the resolu
tion of the ambipolar transport equation in the base. It is shown here
by a numerical simulation of the complete structure, within the frame
work of the drift-diffusion model, that both the exponential current d
ependence: J alpha exp(eVa/2kT) as well as the Yue et al. approximatio
n are valid only in the limiting case of a strongly extrinsic short ba
se diode. (C) 1996 American Institute of Physics.