Wr. Xing et al., FISH DETECTION OF HER-2 NEU ONCOGENE AMPLIFICATION IN EARLY-ONSET BREAST-CANCER/, Breast cancer research and treatment, 39(2), 1996, pp. 203-212
HER-2/neu (c-erbB-2) gene amplification based on Southern blotting or
immunohistochemistry has been shown to be predictive of poor outcome i
n breast cancer occurring in women over 40, but there is little data o
n the role of HER-2/neu in young women with breast cancer, many of who
m may have inherited BRCA1 or other predisposing genes. The present st
udy used fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) on archival specimen
s of breast cancer from 37 women under the age of 40 to evaluate the r
ole of HER-2/neu amplification in this cohort, and to also evaluate th
e efficacy of FISH for quantifying amplification. The frequency of pri
mary tumors with a greater than fourfold increase in gene copy number
was found to be 38%, which is similar to the frequency of amplificatio
n reported in Southern blot studies in older women. However, the great
er sensitivity of FISH enabled detection of low level amplification (m
ore than 2 but less than 8 gene copies), which was found in an additio
nal 30% of the tumors. Patients with low level amplification demonstra
ted a 54% recurrence rate, compared to 86% in those with high amplific
ation and 17% in those with no amplification. HER-2/neu amplification
appeared to be more prognostic of recurrence than nodal status, with 4
5% of node negative tumors recurring compared to 62% of those which we
re node positive, nor was tumor size predictive of recurrence in this
cohort since tumors of 2 cm or less recurred in 44% of cases compared
to 57% of those larger than 2 cm. Thus, this study demonstrates that F
ISH is a reproducible and sensitive technique for detecting HER-2/neu
amplification, and that amplification of the oncogene is the strongest
independent indicator of recurrence of breast cancer in young women.