P. Gonin et al., COMPARISON OF THE EFFICACY OF REPLICATION-DEFECTIVE ADENOVIRUS AND NYVAC POXVIRUS AS VACCINE VECTORS IN MICE, Vaccine, 14(11), 1996, pp. 1083-1087
Adenovirus and poxvirus recombinant vectors are more and more used as
live experimental vaccines. In order to compare the efficacy of these
vectors to elicit serological response and protection against challeng
e, two recombinants carrying the same gene (pseudorabies virus gD) wer
e used as experimental vaccines in mice, a permissive species to pseud
orabies infection. Two routes were tested: intramuscular (i.m.) and in
tranasal (i.n.) in order to try to stimulate general and mucosal immun
e responses. Several doses ranging from 10(2.9) to 10(8.9) TCID50, dep
ending on the vaccines were tested. The estimated log10 (PD50) for the
i.m. route were 7.1 +/- 0.2 for the adenovirus vector (Ad-gD), and 7.
6 +/- 0.2 for the Nyvac vector (vP900). For the i.n. route, log10 (PD5
0) of Ad-gD was 7.1 +/- 0.2, and was higher than 7.9 for vP900. While
the adenovirus vector proved more efficient than the poxviral vector t
o elicit antibody response, only a slight difference was observed when
comparing the survival times of animals after challenge. Adenovirus w
as found better only for the 10(7.9) TCID50 dose, when inoculated i.m.
Intranasal vaccination appeared efficient only with the adenovirus ve
ctor for the TCID50 10(8.9) dose. Copyright (C) 1996 Elsevier Science
Ltd.