Ma. Leon et J. Rasanen, NEURAL-NETWORK-BASED DETECTION OF ESOPHAGEAL INTUBATION IN ANESTHETIZED PATIENTS, Journal of clinical monitoring, 12(2), 1996, pp. 165-169
Objective. To test whether a neural network-based method could differe
ntiate between tracheal and esophageal intubation in anesthetized pati
ents by recognizing breathing circuit pressure and flow waveform patte
rns. Methods. Tracheal tubes were placed in the trachea and in the eso
phagus of adult patients undergoing elective operations. After ensurin
g for proper oxygenation, ventilator settings were changed to 5 ml/kg
tidal volume (VT) and 15 cpm and circuit pressure and flow were record
ed for 15 seconds. Then, the breathing circuit was switched to the tub
e placed in the esophagus, and signals were recorded for an additional
Ii-second period. During offline analysis, individual waveforms were
separated. Tracheal breaths were labeled with a score of 1 while esoph
ageal ''breaths'' were labeled with -1. A neural network was defined t
o learn to associate waveforms to their corresponding scores. Data fro
m 54% of the patients were used to train the neural network. Data from
the remaining subjects were used for testing. Results. Forty-six pati
ents were studied. Neural network training was achieved with 100 trach
eal and 94 esophageal waveforms from 25 patients. Neural network perfo
rmance was tested on 84 tracheal and 76 esophageal waveforms from 21 s
ubjects. The neural network assigned scores of 0.99 +/- 0.05 (mean +/-
SD) to tracheal waveforms and -0.99 +/- 0.03 to esophageal waveforms.
The difference between mean esophageal and tracheal scores was -1.99
with a 99.999% confidence range of -2.01 to -1.96. Any arbitrary cutof
f threshold, ranging between -0.76 and 0.7, separated tracheal and eso
phageal score regions, yielding no false positive or negative results.
Conclusion. A neural network differentiated consistently tracheal fro
m esophageal intubation when the ventilation test-mode was used. The v
entilation mode employed is feasible in most adult patients undergoing
elective procedures under general anesthesia. Further research is req
uired to train neural networks to recognize esophageal intubation in d
ifferent age groups and when different ventilation modes are applied.