Ma. Annunziata et al., PHYSICIANS AND DEATH - COMMENTS AND BEHAVIOR OF 605 DOCTORS IN THE NORTHEAST OF ITALY, Supportive care in cancer, 4(5), 1996, pp. 334-340
Citations number
19
Categorie Soggetti
Oncology,Rehabilitation,"Medicine, General & Internal
The aim of this study was to determine the influence of socio-demograp
hic and professional factors on physicians' attitudes to the terminall
y ill. Between May 1992 and May 1993, a survey was conducted in the pr
ovince of Pordenone (north-east, Italy) in order to analyse a number o
f specific issues, such as emotional involvement, the need for aggress
ive treatments and the communication of diagnosis and prognosis. After
obtaining a list of board-certified physicians from the Medical Assoc
iation office in Pordenone, a modification of the cancer questionnaire
of Haley and Blanchard (QSPT) was mailed to 916 doctors. Of these, 60
5 (60%; 487 male, 118 female; mean age 41+/-11 SD) returned the comple
ted questionnaire. Within the group of responders, we identified three
main subgroups, according to their type of activity: general practiti
oners (175, 29%), hospital doctors (235, 39%) and other doctors (195,
32%). In age, sex and activity, the only significant difference betwee
n responders and non-responders was age (mean age 41 and 43 years resp
ectively), Most of the responders (77%) stated that they were able to
deal with the terminally ill patient and his/her needs; 44%, however,
admitted that patients' anxiety is sometimes unbearable. For the vast
majority of the doctors polled (91%), providing a comfortable environm
ent for an incurable patient was more important than pursuing aggressi
ve treatment, but only 44% were convinced of the uselessness of aggres
sive care. To the question on whether to disclose information about im
minent death to allow patients to prepare spiritually, 37% answered ''
No'', 38% ''Yes'', and 25% were uncertain. Almost all responders (95%)
, however, believed in the beneficial effect of hope on the terminally
ill, Our results suggest that doctors' professional and, most of all,
sociodemographic and cultural factors determine the relationship with
the patient on both the emotional and the clinical decision-making le
vels.