The parameter nu = partial derivative lnv(s)/partial derivative lnv(p)
, the ratio of relative S to P velocity heterogeneity, can be measured
seismically and is important in determining the mineral physics of th
e deep mantle. However, seismic results are inconclusive because they
have generally been based on P and S velocity models which are similar
, but not proportional, and which are derived from seismic data sets i
n different frequency ranges and sample the mantle in different ways.
Hence current values of nu are subject to inconsistencies which arise
from comparing models of differing resolution. Furthermore, heterogene
ity within the Earth may be frequency dependent, and this characterist
ic may also bias v. We overcome these difficulties by computing P and
S models from data sets with the same period and similar data coverage
s and by deriving the ratio in its most rigorous form, whereby we assu
me proportionality of P and S models and calculate nu as a proportiona
lity factor. We proceed by jointly inverting P and S arrival time data
from the International Seismological Centre between the years 1964 an
d 1993 for ratios and compressional models expanded to at most degree
8 laterally in terms of spherical harmonics and up to degree 6 in dept
h in terms of Legendre polynomials. We also quantify the sensitivity o
f our results to data weighting and three-dimensional model parameteri
zation and determine to what depth we are justified in assuming propor
tionality of P and S heterogeneity. We parameterize nu in terms of Leg
endre polynomials and find that there is an insignificant improvement
in variance reduction beyond degree 1. Hence we find that nu increases
linearly from 1.7 to 2.6 between 700 and 2000 km depth, which is the
greatest depth to which we believe our results are reliable. We also c
ompare our results with those from theoretical mineral physics and fin
d that seismically derived values are significantly larger and increas
ing at a greater rate. Reconciliation of these results requires at lea
st modifications to the physical mechanisms currently postulated.