SUBALTERNITY AND INTERNATIONAL-LAW - THE PROBLEMS OF GLOBAL COMMUNITYAND THE INCOMMENSURABILITY OF DIFFERENCE

Authors
Citation
D. Otto, SUBALTERNITY AND INTERNATIONAL-LAW - THE PROBLEMS OF GLOBAL COMMUNITYAND THE INCOMMENSURABILITY OF DIFFERENCE, Social & legal studies, 5(3), 1996, pp. 337
Citations number
69
Categorie Soggetti
Social, Sciences, Interdisciplinary",Law,"Criminology & Penology
Journal title
ISSN journal
09646639
Volume
5
Issue
3
Year of publication
1996
Database
ISI
SICI code
0964-6639(1996)5:3<337:SAI-TP>2.0.ZU;2-T
Abstract
This article draws on the work of the Indian Subaltern Studies collect ive to explore the possibilities for imagining processes whereby non-d ominant, non-elite, subaltern individuals and groupings might particip ate as subjects of international law. It suggests that the decolonizat ion agenda of the UN Charter has repeated imperialism, albeit with a n ew legal and moral appearance, in the European production of the postc olonial nation-state. Parallels are drawn between the G77's strategy t o counter European hegemony through the promotion of a New World Econo mic Order and the struggle of the Indian nationalists for independence . In both endeavours, European knowledge systems were uncritically emb raced, and, as a result, subaltern experience incommensurable with the European imagination was silenced. It is suggested that the post-Cold War narratives of global democratization create new opportunities for contesting subaltern erasure, and some strategies for developing alte rnative practices, suggested by Subaltern Studies analyses, are canvas sed.