DETECTION OF CORONARY CALCIFICATION WITH ELECTRON-BEAM COMPUTED-TOMOGRAPHY - EVALUATION OF INTEREXAMINATION REPRODUCIBILITY AND COMPARISON OF 3 IMAGE-ACQUISITION PROTOCOLS
Sj. Wang et al., DETECTION OF CORONARY CALCIFICATION WITH ELECTRON-BEAM COMPUTED-TOMOGRAPHY - EVALUATION OF INTEREXAMINATION REPRODUCIBILITY AND COMPARISON OF 3 IMAGE-ACQUISITION PROTOCOLS, The American heart journal, 132(3), 1996, pp. 550-558
The purpose of this investigation was to determine the variability of
electron-beam computed tomography (EBCT) measurement of coronary calci
fication by using two commonly employed image-acquisition protocols an
d to compare this variability with that of a new image-acquisition pro
tocol. We performed three EBCT scans within 15 minutes on each of 324
consecutive high-risk, asymptomatic subjects participating in an ongoi
ng epidemiologic research investigation. Subjects were divided into th
ree groups: group 1 (n = 175) received two scans with a standard 20-sl
ice, 3 mm slice thickness image-acquisition protocol and a third scan
with the new 20-slice, 6 mm slice thickness protocol; group 2 (n = 77)
received two scans with a new 6 mm slice thickness image-acquisition
protocol and a third scan with a standard 20-slice, 3 mm slice thickne
ss protocol; group 3 (n = 72) received two scans with a 30-slice, 3 mm
slice thickness image-acquisition protocol and a third scan with a 20
-slice, 6 mm slice thickness protocol. Calcium score, calcium mass est
imate, and calcium volume estimate were determined for each scan. We c
ompared retest variability of calcium measurements for each of the thr
ee image-acquisition protocols. The variability of the new 6 mm slice
thickness protocol was significantly lower than that of either the 20-
slice 3 mm slice thickness protocol (p = 0.009) or the 30-slice 3 mm s
lice thickness protocol (p = 0.02) for measurement of calcium score, m
ass, or volume. Retest reproducibility for all three image-acquisition
protocols was low; however, the 20-slice 6 mm slice thickness protoco
l gave reproducibility superior to either of the 3 mm slice thickness
protocols. Variability of absolute indices increased, and variability
of relative indices decreased as the value of these indices increased.
EBCT is not sufficiently reproducible to allow serial quantitation of
coronary calcium in individual patients over relatively short periods
(<2 years).