A. Tonhasca et al., EVALUATION OF THE POWER-LAW AND PATCHINESS REGRESSIONS WITH REGRESSION DIAGNOSTICS, Journal of economic entomology, 89(6), 1996, pp. 1477-1484
We used regression diagnostics to evaluate the robustness of the least
-squares regression method for estimating the power law and patchiness
regression parameters for 3 data sets of insect counts, specifically
for the Bemisia argentifolii Bellows & Perring, and the squash bug, An
asa tristis (De Geer). Extreme values in the independent variable, x,
and dependent variable, y were detected with the leverage term, h(i),
and standardized residuals, e(s), respectively. The assumption of homo
geneity of variances was evaluated with plots of e(s) against s for al
l regressions, and significant autocorrelations were tested with the D
urbin-Watson statistic. For both techniques, we compared least-squares
regression results for all data with regressions obtained after outli
er data points were removed. We also calculated power law regressions
excluding means (m) <2 and variances (s(2)) <4 to reduce possible bias
resulting from small mean densities. Outlier data points did not have
a significant effect on the power law regressions, but they had a str
ong influence on some patchiness regressions. The distribution of stan
dardized residuals of some power law regressions were biased toward po
sitive values for low mean densities, indicating underestimation of va
riances. Additionally, least-squares regression estimates for m greate
r than or equal to 2, s(2) greater than or equal to 4 indicated a gene
ral increase in slopes for the power law. The distribution of standard
ized residuals for patchiness regressions indicated strong heterosceda
sticity; therefore, the assumption of constant variance for y was not
fulfilled. Our results show that suitability of least-squares regressi
on assumptions should be considered whenever pest management decisions
are based on the power law or patchiness regressions.