T. Lloyd et al., THE EFFECT OF CALCIUM SUPPLEMENTATION AND TANNER STAGE ON BONE-DENSITY, CONTENT AND AREA IN TEENAGE WOMEN, Osteoporosis international, 6(4), 1996, pp. 276-283
One hundred and twelve Caucasian girls, 11.9 +/- 0.5 years of age al e
ntry, were randomized into a 24-month, double-masked, placebo-controll
ed trial to determine the effect of calcium supplementation on bone mi
neral content, bane area and bone density. Supplementation was 500 mg
calcium as calcium citrate malate (CCM) per day. Controls received pla
cebo pills, and compliance of both groups averaged 72%, Bone mineral c
ontent, bone mineral area and bone mineral density of the lumbar spine
and total body were measured by dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DSA
). Calcium intake hom dietary sources averaged 953 mg/day for the enti
re study group. The supplemented group received, on average, an additi
onal 360 mg calcium/day from CCM. At baseline and after 24 months, the
two groups did not differ with respect to anthropometric measurements
, urinary reproductive hormone levels or any measurement of pubertal p
rogression. The supplemented group had greater increases of total body
bone measures: content 39.9% versus 35.7% (p = 0.01), area 24.2% vers
us 22.5% (p = 0.15) and density 12.2% versus 10.1% (p = 0.005). Region
-of-interest analyses showed that the supplemented group had greater g
ains compared with the control group for bone. mineral density, conten
t and area, In particular, In the lumbar spine and pelvis, the gains m
ade by the supplemented group were 12%-24% greater than the increases
made by the control group, Bone acquisition rates in the two study gro
ups were further compared by subdividing the groups into those with be
low- or above-median Values for Tanner score and dietary calcium intak
e, In subjects with below-median Tanner scores, bone acquisition was n
ot affected by calcium supplementation or dietary calicum level. Howev
er, the calcium supplemented subjects with above-median Tanner had hig
her bone acqusition rates than the placebo group with above-median Tan
ner scores. Relative to the placebo group. the supplemented group had
increased yearly gains of bone content, area and density which represe
nted about 1.5% of adult female values. Such increases, if held to adu
lt skeletal maturity, could provide protection against future risk of
osteoporotic fractures.