Jc. Smart et Ep. Stjohn, ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE AND EFFECTIVENESS IN HIGHER-EDUCATION - A TESTOF THE CULTURE TYPE AND STRONG CULTURE HYPOTHESES, Educational evaluation and policy analysis, 18(3), 1996, pp. 219-241
Two of the more promising lines of inquiry in efforts to understand th
e hypothesized linkage between organizational culture and effectivenes
s have focused on the differential effectiveness of organizations depe
nding on their dominant culture type and their culture strength. The p
rimary purpose of this study was to determine whether these two lines
of inquiry operate in an independent or conditional manner in explaini
ng the hypothesized linkage between organizational culture and the per
formance of a sample of four-year colleges and universities. The findi
ngs provide support for both lines of inquiry, albeit not entirely in
a manner suggested by their respective proponents. For example, while
culture type has a decidedly stronger independent effect on institutio
nal performance than culture strength, the differences are clearly mor
e pronounced on campuses with ''strong'' rather than ''weak'' cultures
. The implications of these findings for research on and efforts to im
prove the performance of colleges and universities are discussed.