Pj. Blanchfield et Ms. Ridgway, USE OF SEEPAGE METERS TO MEASURE GROUNDWATER-FLOW AT BROOK TROUT REDDS, Transactions of the American Fisheries Society, 125(5), 1996, pp. 813-818
Anomalous influxes of water into unfilled collection bags can greatly
overestimate volume and flow rate data from seepage meters. From stati
c tank trials, initially empty collection bags (4,500 mL capacity) att
ached to seepage meters gained significantly more water relative to ba
gs prefilled to 1,000 mL. Data from a study of groundwater flow at red
ds of brook trout Salvelinus fontinalis in Scott Lake, Ontario, indica
te that the use of unfilled bags biases seepage meter data. At these r
edds, the anomalous influx of water into unfilled bags was significant
(intercept of regression equation, y = 275 mL); however, this influx
was sufficiently reduced when prefilled bags were used (y = 34 mL). Ou
r data suggest that even at high how rates (22-169 mL . m(-2). min(-1)
), seepage measures can be inflated by an order of magnitude when init
ially empty bags are used. Because of this anomaly, previous measures
of ground water flow at brook trout redds with unfilled bags are proba
bly not representative of natural flow rates. Our estimates of groundw
ater flow at brook trout redds in Scott Lake (6-296 mL . m(-2). min(-1
)) are very similar to the range in groundwater flow found in lake and
stream redds (4-340 mL . m(-2). min(-1)) by other methods. We suggest
the use of prefilled collection bags (filled to 1,000 mL) and conform
ity in measurement units (mL . m(-2). min(-1)) when groundwater how is
measured with seepage meters.