U. Schumann et al., IN-SITU OBSERVATIONS OF PARTICLES IN JET AIRCRAFT EXHAUSTS AND CONTRAILS FOR DIFFERENT SULFUR-CONTAINING FUELS, JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-ATMOSPHERES, 101(D3), 1996, pp. 6853-6869
The impact of sulfur oxides on particle formation and contrails is inv
estigated in the exhaust plumes of a twin-engine jet aircraft. Differe
nt fuels were used with sulfur mass fractions of 170 and 5500 ppm in t
he fuel, one lower than average, the other above the specification lim
it of standard Jet-Al fuel. During various phases of the same flight,
the two engines burnt either high- or low-sulfur fuel or different fue
ls in the two engines. Besides visual, photographic, and video observa
tions from close distance, in situ measurements were made within the p
lumes at plume ages of 20 to 30 s, at altitudes between 9 and 9.5 km,
and temperatures between -49 and -55 degrees C, when the visible contr
ail was about 2 km long. The data include particle number densities fo
r particles larger than 7 nm, 18 nm, 120 nm, and 1 mu m in diameter, t
ogether with wind, temperature and humidity measurements. The observat
ions show visible and measurable differences between contrails caused
by the different sulfur levels. At ambient temperatures 5 K below the
threshold temperature for contrail onset, the plume became visible abo
ut 10 m after the engine exit for high sulfur content, but 15 m after
the engine exit for low sulfur content. The higher sulfur emission cau
sed a larger optical thickness of the contrail shortly after onset, wi
th slightly brown-colored contrail when the Sun was behind the observe
r, and more contrast when viewed against the Sun. The high-sulfur cont
rail grew more quickly but also evaporated earlier than the low-sulfur
contrail. At plume ages of about 20 s, each engine plume was diluted
to an effective diameter of 20 m. The plumes contained many subvisible
particles. Peak number densities were 30,000 cm(-3) for particles of
diameter above 7 nm and 15,000 cm(-3) above 18 nm. The latter is a lit
tle larger than the estimated number of soot particles emitted. The hi
gh-sulfur plume shows more particles than the low-sulfur plume. The di
fferences are about 25% for particles above 7 nm and about 50% above I
s nm. The results indicate that part of the fuel sulfur is converted t
o sulfuric acid which nucleates with water vapor heterogeneously on so
ot or nucleates acid droplets homogeneously which then coagulate partl
y with soot. During descent through the level of contrail onset, the h
igh-sulfur contrail remained visible at slightly lower altitude (25 to
50 m) or higher temperature (0.2 to 0.4 K). At least for average to h
igh sulfur contents, aircraft generate an invisible aerosol trail whic
h enhances the background level of condensation nuclei, in particular
in regions with dense air traffic at northern latitudes and near the t
ropopause.