Rw. Nightingale et al., GLOBAL CF2CL2 MEASUREMENTS BY UARS CRYOGENIC LIMB ARRAY ETALON SPECTROMETER - VALIDATION BY CORRELATIVE DATA AND A MODEL, JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-ATMOSPHERES, 101(D6), 1996, pp. 9711-9736
The cryogenic limb array etalon spectrometer (CLAES) onboard the Upper
Atmosphere Research Satellite (UARS) has obtained the first global me
asurements of CF2Cl2 over six seasons, for which 388 days have been pr
ocessed in data version 7 for the period from January 9, 1992, to May
5, 1993. The CLAES measurements provide a near-global view of this str
atospheric species, greatly extending the altitude, latitude, and seas
onal coverage of previous measurements. This work evaluates CLAES vers
ion 7 data set quality. To arrive at estimates of experimental error,
we compared the CLAES CF2Cl2 profiles with all of the available correl
ative data from balloon and space-borne sensors, and we looked at the
repeatability of multiple profiles in the same location. In addition,
we carried out empirical estimates of experimental error based on know
ledge of instrument characteristics, and we performed consistency chec
ks using the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory two-dimensional (L
LNL-2D) model and the CLAES N2O data set. Both the range of mean diffe
rences between CLAES and the available correlative data and the empiri
cal estimates of the instrument systematic error indicate a CF2Cl2 pro
file systematic error of 14% over the range of 18.7 through 32 km and
22% for 33-35 km and 16-18 km. These systematic errors are applicable
in the spring through fall seasons for the midlatitude region and all
seasons in the tropical region. The CF2Cl2 estimated random errors, wh
ich are close to the observed data repeatability, are 32 to 11 pptv be
tween 17 and 32 km and translate to an average 9% in the low to midstr
atosphere. The altitude range of best confidence for the CF2Cl2 mixing
ratio profiles is 18.7 to 32 km (similar to 68 to 10 mbar), to which
we assign an accuracy (root-sum-square of systematic and random errors
) of similar to 17%. In the tropics the profiles from 16 to about 26 k
m may sometimes be biased low by up to 14% due to a data processing al
gorithm constraint. The CLAES CF2Cl2 global fields show generally good
spatial correlation and exhibit the major morphological and seasonal
features seen in other global tracer field data. Overall, the results
of this validation exercise indicate that the CLAES version 7 CF2Cl2 d
ata set, within the limitations discussed in the paper, can be used fo
r quantitative and qualitative studies of stratospheric structure and
dynamics.