Pf. Bell, PREDICTING LIMING NEEDS OF SOYBEAN USING SOIL-PH, ALUMINUM, AND MANGANESE SOIL TESTS, Communications in soil science and plant analysis, 27(13-14), 1996, pp. 2749-2764
Whether a tropical-soil should be limed or not for a particular crop i
s strongly dependent on the levels of soil aluminum (Al) which can be
determined with soil tests. Soil pH is used to predict whether lime is
needed in less-weathered soils, although some evidence indicates a so
il Al test would be more accurate. The objectives of this study were t
o determine and to compare the accuracies of four soil tests to:separa
te soils requiring lime from those that do not, and to determine the c
ause of acid-soil injury to soybean [Glycine max (L.) Merr.]. Soybean
was grown in the greenhouse on four surface soils representing the maj
or land resource areas of Louisiana and were amended with eight rates
of lime, yields determined, and soils analyzed for soil pH, extractabl
e Al, CaCl2-extractable Al, CaCl2-extractable manganese (Mn), and Al s
aturation. Acid-soil injury in soybean grown on the Litro clay and Sto
ugh fsl was probably caused by soil-Al effects while low soil calcium
(Ca) and high soil Mn was likely responsible for lower yields from the
Mahan fsl. Leaf Ca from the limed Mahan-soil treatment was 5-fold gre
ater and leaf-Mn 7-fold less than control levels. Regression analyses'
R(2) values were similar for all soil tests except for CaCl2-extracta
ble Mn, which was lower. Soil tests were compared across soil type by
selecting treatments that had the same 85% relative yield. Using this
data subset, there was no difference in the soil pH among the four soi
ls, while there were significant differences among soils for all other
soil test measurements indicating the superiority of soil pH for iden
tifying acid-soil injury. Critical rest values were 5.1 soil pH, 30 mg
kg(-1) extractable Al, 7% Al saturation, 0.7 mg . kg(-1) CaCl2-extrac
table Al, and 9 mg . kg(-1) CaCl2-extractable Mn.