Twenty-year-old overstocked naturally regenerated yellow birch (Betula
alleghaniensis Britton) were thinned near Thessalon, Ontario. Treatme
nts consisted of either a control, or the removal of all competing tre
es at 1, 2, 3, or 4 m around the boles of the crop trees, The size of
the openings created around the crop tree crowns was found to be more
strongly correlated to diameter, clear bole length, and crown incremen
t than the removal of competing trees using fixed distance from the st
em. Crop trees responded well to thinning. Five-year diameter incremen
t and crown diameter growth were positively correlated to size of the
opening created around the crop tree crown. However, the relationship
between height growth and size of canopy opening was weak. Clear bole
length was found to be negatively correlated to the size of canopy ope
ning. Few epicormic sprouts developed on the stems when all competing
trees were removed at 1, 2, or 3 m around the crop tree boles. However
, release at 4 m greatly increased the number and size of epicormic sp
routs. Providing about a 15-m(2) opening around the crop tree crown, c
orresponding to approximately a 3-m removal of competing trees around
the bole, provided a good balance between diameter increment and stem
quality maintenance.