G. Bodenmann, GENDER DIFFERENCES CONCERNING DEPRESSION - DO THE EMOTIONAL-REACTIONSIN DAILY-LIFE LEAD TO DEPRESSIONS, Zeitschrift fur klinische Psychologie, Psychiatrie und Psychotherapie, 44(4), 1996, pp. 362-381
In this article, we discuss the question as to why more women suffer f
rom depression than do men. Although many studies have been conducted
in an attempt to better understand the gender differences concerning d
epression, most of the work done in this field has focused upon depres
sive patients. Consequently, insufficient knowledge concerning the mec
hanisms connected to gender which lead to depression exists. We assume
that depression is a consequence of an already depressiogenic cogniti
ve style practiced in everyday life. Women tend to deal in a different
(and more negative) manner with failure and frustration in daily stre
ss situations than do men. Women's behavior is characterized by a dysf
unctional attributional style, by less appropriate goals, more negativ
e coping strategies and a less favourable primary appraisal. In additi
on, their emotional reactions depend to a great extent upon these intr
apsychic maladaptive processes. These daily life patterns in turn pred
ispose women to depression in situations oi great stress (critical lif
e events, chronic stress, etc.). Although these ideas in themselves ar
e not new, the methodological approach presented in this study address
es this issue in a novel may for the following two reasons: Firstly, r
ather than focusing upon depression, we focus upon sadness (as a norma
l range emotional response) in an effort to undercover the precursors
of depression. Secondly, we use a particularly broad data base (selfre
port data; independant observer ratings; experimental data; ratings fr
om field studies, etc.). The results found in this study support our h
ypothesis that the way in which women manage failure in stress situati
ons is more dysfunctional than the way men cope with similar situation
s and that Nomen react with more sadness than do men. These findings c
annot. be explained solely by a higher level of emotional expressivene
ss in our female subjects.