Gc. Defontenay et al., STATISTICAL COMPARISON OF 2 DIFFERENT MET HODS FOR DETERMINING ANTIFUNGAL ACTIVITY, Journal de mycologie medicale, 6(3), 1996, pp. 129-132
Purpose. When perfecting a new antifungal agent, efficacy evaluation i
s based on in vitro tests. Numerous methods have been developed but pr
esent standardisation problems, in particular for filamentous fungi. T
he amount of glucose consumption in the culture medium allows the fung
us growth to be measured. This amount is used to evaluate antifungal e
fficacy by comparing the difference of consumption in a treated and un
treated fungus. To validate this glucose test, it was compared to the
traditional turbidimetric method. Methods. In a Yeast Nitrogen Base li
quid medium supplemented with Glucose (YNBG), a Candida albicans strai
n was treated with various amphotericin B concentrations. Different in
cubation conditions were carried out. After incubation, absorbance and
glucose concentration were measured for each sample. Inhibition perce
nrages were calculated from both method by comparison with the untreat
ed fungus. Results were compared by using the Student t-test (paired s
amples method). For the turbidimetric method, a calibration curve betw
een absorbance and cell concentration was performed to interpret absor
bances superior to 1. Results. The two techniques statistically gave t
he same results (p < 0.05) for the study of amphotericin B against a C
. albicans strain. Discussion/Conclusion. This glucose test gives part
ial inhibition percentages which are useful when azole antifungals are
involved. Furthermore, this technique can be used with filamentous fu
ngi, for which partial inhibitions are frequent and interpretation of
minimum inhibitory concentration values difficult.