M. Ruedi et L. Fumagalli, GENETIC-STRUCTURE OF GYMNURES (GENUS HYLOMYS, ERINACEIDAE) ON CONTINENTAL ISLANDS OF SOUTHEAST-ASIA - HISTORICAL EFFECTS OF FRAGMENTATION, Journal of zoological systematics and evolutionary research, 34(3), 1996, pp. 153-162
Eustatic sea level changes during Pleistocene climatic fluctuations pr
oduced several cycles of connection-isolation among continental island
s of the Sunda shelf. To explore the potential effects of these fluctu
ations, we reconstructed a model of the vicariant events that separate
d these islands, based on bathymetric information. Among many possible
scenarios, two opposite phylogenetic patterns of evolution were predi
cted for terrestrial organisms living in this region: one is based on
the classical allopatric speciation mode of evolution, while the other
is the outcome of a sequential dispersal colonization of the archipel
ago. We tested the applicability of these predictions with an analysis
of sequence variation of the cytochrome b gene from several taxa of H
ylomys. They were sampled throughout SE-Asia and the Sunda islands. Hi
gh levels of haplotype differentiation characterize the different isla
nd taxa. Such levels of differentiation support the existence of sever
al allopatric species, as was suggested by previous allozyme and morph
ological data. Also in accordance with previous results, the occurrenc
e of two sympatric species from Sumatra is suggested by their strongly
divergent haplotypes. One species, Hylomys suillus maxi, is found bot
h on Sumatra and in Peninsular Malaysia, while the other, H. parvus, i
s endemic to Sumatra. Its closest relative is H. suillus dorsalis from
Borneo. Phylogenetic reconstructions also demonstrate the existence o
f a Sundaic clade composed of all island taxa, as opposed to those fro
m the continent. Although there is no statistical support for either p
roposed biogeographic model of evolution, we argue that the sequential
dispersal scenario is more appropriate to describe the genetic variat
ion found among the Hylomys taxa. However, despite strong differentiat
ion among island haplotypes, the cladistic relationships between some
island taxa could not be resolved. We argue that this is evidence of a
rapid radiation, suggesting that the separation of the islands may ha
ve been perceived as a simultaneous event rather than as a succession
of vicariant events. Furthermore, the estimates of divergence times be
tween the haplotypes of these taxa suggest that this radiation may act
ually have predated the climatic fluctuations of the Pleistocene. Furt
her refinement of the initial palaeogeographic models of evolution are
therefore needed to account for these results.